Tuesday, May 1, 2018

Lal Kiley ka tender


The Mandi House area in the Lutyen’s Delhi is particularly busy on weekends. The miniscule minority, which identifies itself as theatre lovers, descends on the three public auditoriums to get their fill of art and culture. On rare occasions one might get to watch an engaging, high quality production. On other occasions one has to make do with either Taj Mahal ka tender or Gadhey ki barat. Taj Mahal ka tender, a satire, is what came to my mind when opinions and comments on Red Fort started pouring in on my social media timelines. The Dalmia Bharat Group has adopted the Red Fort under the government’s Adopt a Heritage initiative, which requires spending on public infrastructure and no profit making. The adoption was widely covered in the media, sometimes with misleading headlines like, “are Marwaris taking over our national heritage?”

I can really do with some upkeep
As expected, the rent an outrage section of “intellectuals” started twisting the story. They were “appalled” and “heartbroken” because the Red Fort has been “auctioned”.  Even the wannabe comedy rag ScoopWhoop compiled all the outrage in an image heavy post, full of lies. At this point AltNews should have picked up the fake stories on Red Fort auction and set the record straight. Oh! But wait, AltNews is only interested in what the liberals consider to be fake. Since the liberals themselves were howling to “save” the Red Fort, AltNews perhaps gave this fake story a miss.

So what is the story behind the so called auction of Red Fort? The government in 2017 decided to do something about the abysmal standards of public services provided at our national monuments. Lack of proper signage, toilets, clean drinking water, sitting spaces, etc. steal the joy of visiting our heritage. In an attempt to improve the facilities, which the government obviously failed to deliver on its own, the Ministry of Tourism decided to invite private participation.

The Ministry’s demands were assessed by a Standing Committee of the Parliament. The committee was headed by none other than Shri Derek O’ Brien, Member of Parliament, Trinamool Congress. Others prominent members in the committee (31 members) were former aviation minister Praful Patel, former minister for Social Justice and Empowerment, Shailja Kumar, former CPM member Ritabrata Banerjee and former RJD MP Pappu Yadav.

The Committee after deliberations made its recommendations on March 1, 2018. The report can be read here. Paragraph 112 on page 48, of the report says, The Committee notes that the initiative of Adopt a Heritage is a welcome step on the part of the Ministry of Tourism. The parties, whose members signed on the report are now spreading fake news, telling people how the government is selling off national monuments. Foremost being Shri O’ Brien himself.

The fact is that there is no sell off of any monument. The guidelines of the Adopt a Heritage scheme can be read here. The prime focus of the scheme is to rope in a private agency, which according to the report can be an NGO, individual or a company, to build, operate and maintain public facilities. The organisation will not be involved in any restoration work of the monument, neither will it “own” the monument.

All the outrage among the liberals, as usual, is not motivated by facts but by feelings. And facts don’t matter when their agenda is only to criticise the government. As long as they can create hysteria by peddling their lies, it serves their agenda. Then there is the gullible janta, which eats out of their hands and exponentially spreads their lies, without any fact check.